by cdnlad75 » Fri Feb 19, 2010 10:20:23 PM
I have been banking with PC Financial for 9 of the last 10 years (I moved to Scotiabank for one year in 2008 and then moved back to PC Financial in 2009). I originally moved my chequing account to PC Financial back in 2001 after TD bank merged with Canada Trust and my $5.00 unlimited banking monthly fee climbed to $12.95 and I was not willing to pay that amount of money just to access my money.
To put it into perspective, PC Financial (PCF) is a good choice if prefer to do most of your banking electronically via the internet, Interac and via ATM bank machines. You have access to all of CIBC's bank machines free of charge to deposit and withdraw money and PCF also allows you to hook up other bank accounts in your name to transfer money to and from other Canadian bank accounts (think of how ING Direct does business). You have access to the same types of bill payments that any CIBC customer has and of course free Interac, and free paper unlimited paper cheques.
As you have provided with paper cheques, you can of course setup direct withdrawals and direct deposits as you would with any of the traditional banks (etc. payroll deposit and automatic car payment withdrawal).
Having said the above, one huge electronic glitch with PCF is that they currently do not offer Interac Email money transfer. With many credit unions now offering Interac Email, it is starting to show as a glaring point in PCF's portfolio of services. I have called PCF about this (their main telephone service centre is in New Brunswick and not in India) and they continue to say that they are looking into it, however I personally I believe that CIBC, the bank that PCF piggy backs off of, will not allow PCF to use their Interac Email money transfer service for fear that CIBC customers may leave CIBC to go to PCF, but that is just my personal opinion.
Where PCF shines in in rates. They offer a low standardized borrowing rate for their lines of credits and loans and offer relatively high interest rates on their savings account products, or at least close to par with ING Direct, one of PCF's main internet savings competitors.
I do also have the PCF Mastercard, however have found that I like MBNA's new Smart Cash Mastercard better because you get a full 3% cashback spent in all grocery stores you visit and not just 1% cashback that is offered by the PCF Mastercard.
I had no problem opening up a line of credit with PCF, which you have easy access either via paper cheques, online, or through your Interac card, but it took me almost 2 months to finally secure and receive a draft cheque for a car loan I took out back in 2002. I was told that the delay was due high demand for PCF financial loan products, but I think it was more due to lack of staff.
Although I am renting and do not have a mortgage, I do agree with a previous comment made on this blog that you should also have a pay as you go type account with one of the traditional banks in case of emergencies. I have a Scotiabank savings account hooked up to my PCF account and I can transfer money quickly between the two accounts in about two business days. Although PCF does not offer certified cheques, for a fee they will create and courier to you (at your cost) money orders or send wire transfers.
I am rather surprised to read some of the comments on this blog about people having difficulty with PCF's customer service representatives as I have found PCF's representatives to me much more helpful and knowledgeable then those I have dealt with at Scotiabank.
If you demand face to face contact with people to conduct your banking, then PCF is certainty not the bank for you. Although PCF will say that you can visit a kiosk to talk to a banking representative, don't be fooled, these people are not bank tellers, but rather are sales people with limited banking skills who are there specifically just to open up new accounts and getting existing customers new bank cards as ATM machines eat them up.
One positive change PCF has made recently is that if your Interac debit card is compromised, PCF now will make a phone call to your main phone to inform you that your card has been compromised and that you need to visit a Loblaws kisok to get a new card. This is much better than the embarrassment of trying to use your Interac card in the store to later find out that your card has been locked and you cannot access your money until you visit a Loblaws kiosk.
Now, if only PCF could somehow introduce Interac Email Money Transfers and I would be completely satisfied with their portfolio of services.